Skip to content
logo

International Justice Resource Center

International Justice Resource Center

  • View ijrcenter’s profile on Facebook
  • View ijrcenter’s profile on Twitter
  • View ijrcenter’s profile on Instagram
  • View ijrcenter’s profile on LinkedIn
  • View ijrcenter’s profile on YouTube
  • View ijrcenter’s profile on Vimeo
  • About IJRC
    • Who We Are
      • Board of Directors
      • Advisory Board
    • What We Do
      • Online Resource Hub
      • Litigation & Advocacy Support
      • Trainings
    • IJRC in the News
    • Work with IJRC
    • Contact Us
  • Human Rights Law
    • Human Rights Overview
    • Civil & Political Rights
    • Vulnerable Groups
    • Economic, Social & Cultural Rights
    • Country Factsheets
    • Research Aids
      • Books & Articles
      • Civil Society Actors
      • Human Rights Conditions
      • International Human Rights Instruments
      • Jurisprudence & Document Databases
    • Related Areas of Law
      • Asylum & the Rights of Refugees
      • International Criminal Law
      • International Humanitarian Law
      • Regional Integration Agreements
  • Courts & Monitoring Bodies
    • United Nations
      • Human Rights Council
      • Universal Periodic Review
      • Independent Experts
      • Human Rights Treaty Bodies
        • Human Rights Committee
        • Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
        • Committee Against Torture
        • Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women
        • Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination
        • Committee on Enforced Disappearances
        • Committee on Migrant Workers
        • Committee on the Rights of the Child
        • Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities
        • Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture
    • Africa
      • African Court on Human and Peoples’ Rights
      • African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights
      • COMESA Court of Justice
      • East African Court of Justice
      • ECOWAS Court of Justice
      • Southern African Development Community Tribunal
    • Americas
      • Inter-American Court of Human Rights
      • Inter-American Commission on Human Rights
      • Caribbean Court of Justice
      • Central American Court of Justice
      • Court of Justice of the Andean Community
    • Asia
    • Europe
      • European Court of Human Rights
      • European Committee of Social Rights
      • Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights
    • Middle East and North Africa
    • National Bodies
      • National Courts
      • National Human Rights Institutions
      • Truth and Reconciliation Commissions
      • Universal Jurisdiction
    • Hearings & Sessions
    • Other International Bodies
      • International Court of Justice
      • International Criminal Court
      • ICTR
      • ICTY
      • Internationalized Criminal Tribunals
      • International Labour Organization
      • Courts and Tribunals of Regional Economic Communities
  • News & Events
    • News Room
    • IJRC Daily
    • Hearings & Sessions
    • IJRC Events
  • Media & Publications
    • IJRC Publications
    • IJRC Interview Series
    • Educational Videos
      • Advocacy before the Inter-American Human Rights System
      • El Litigio e Incidencia ante el Sistema Interamericano de Derechos Humanos
      • Atuação perante o Sistema Interamericano de Direitos Humanos
      • Pledwaye Devan Sistèm Entè-Ameriken pou Pwoteksyon Dwa Moun
    • Training Sessions
  • Donate

Inter-American Court: States Must Recognize Gender Identity, Same-Sex Marriage

January 16, 2018 IJRC discrimination, economic, social & cultural rights, family, Inter-American System, international human rights, LGBTI rights, regional human rights protection
The Inter-American Court of Human Rights
Credit: CorteIDH

On January 9, 2018, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACtHR), the judicial organ of the human rights system in the Americas, published an advisory opinion holding that Member States of the American Convention on Human Rights have an obligation to permit transgender individuals to change their name and gender on identity documents, to recognize same-sex marriage, and to ensure the economic rights of those in same-sex relationships. [IACtHR Press Release (in Spanish only)] See I/A Court H.R., Obligaciones Estatales en Relación Con el Cambio de Nombre, la Identidad de Género, Y los Derechos Derivados de un Vínculo Entre Parejas del Mismo Sexo. Advisory Opinion OC-24/17. 24 November 2017, para. 229 (in Spanish only). In 2016, Costa Rica filed a request for the advisory opinion, asking the Inter-American Court to clarify two questions arising under the American Convention. The first question was whether States are obligated to provide procedures for name, photo, and gender changes in accordance with an individual’s gender identity, and whether Costa Rica’s practices conform with this obligation. The second question was whether States are obligated to recognize the economic rights derived from a bond between same-sex persons. [IACtHR Press Release] See Obligaciones Estatales en Relación Con el Cambio de Nombre, la Identidad de Género, Y los Derechos Derivados de un Vínculo Entre Parejas del Mismo Sexo. 24 November 2017, para. 1. The Inter-American Court answered in the affirmative to Costa Rica’s questions. [IACtHR Press Release] The finding applies to all 23 States parties to the American Convention.

The opinion has received international recognition for its advancement of LGBTQ rights; the recently appointed Independent Expert on protection against violence and discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity, Victor Madrigal-Borloz, has expressed that “the protections described by the Court in this Advisory Opinion will have an extremely positive impact in addressing stigma, promoting socio-cultural inclusion and furthering legal recognition of gender identity.” [OHCHR Press Release] Although Costa Rica is one of several Latin American countries that do not currently permit same-sex marriage, officials from the Costa Rican government are willing to embrace the Court’s opinion, with Costa Rica’s Vice-President Ana Helena Chacón quoted as saying that the decision would be adopted “in its totality.” [Reuters; BBC].

Gender Identity and the American Convention

The Court concluded that State recognition of one’s gender identity is a vital component of guaranteeing transgender individuals access to the full enjoyment of their human rights. See Obligaciones Estatales en Relación Con el Cambio de Nombre, la Identidad de Género, Y los Derechos Derivados de un Vínculo Entre Parejas del Mismo Sexo. 24 November 2017, para. 103. The opinion relied on the Court’s previous jurisprudence to confirm that Article 1.1 (right to non-discrimination) of the American Convention prohibits discrimination on the basis of one’s gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation, and the Court established that it defines gender identity as an internal and individual experience of gender that may not align with the sex assigned at birth. See id. at paras. 32(f), 68-78.

The Court, first, found that from the right to private life under Article 11 of the American Convention, there is a right to identity, which itself comprises several rights and includes an individual’s gender identity. See id. at paras. 85-92, 101. Further, the Court held that the right to freedom of expression under Article 13 of the American Convention protects the outward projection of identity, including gender identity. See id. at paras. 96-98. The Court held that one’s gender identity should not preclude an individual from receiving any of the rights guaranteed under the American Convention, including protection against all forms of violence, torture, and ill-treatment as well as the guarantee of the rights to health, education, employment, housing, access to social security, freedom of expression, and freedom of association. See id. at para. 101.

With respect to Costa Rica’s question concerning a State’s obligation to provide gender affirming legal procedures, the Inter-American Court found that providing procedures to change one’s name, identifying photograph, and gender on official State registration documents is an extension of the right to non-discrimination based on gender identity, a violation of which could lead to the infringement of other rights. See id. at para. 114-15. Accordingly, States, including Costa Rica, have an obligation under the American Convention to implement such procedures. See id. at para. 116. Moreover, with respect to Costa Rica’s own legislation, the Inter-American Court found that Costa Rican law was compatible with the American Convention, so long as the law is interpreted in a way that provides for an individual’s legal identity to reflect their self-perceived identity. See id. at para. 171.

American Convention’s Protections for Same-Sex Couples

On Costa Rica’s second question, the Inter-American Court reiterated that the American Convention’s protection of family life is not limited to a particular family model. See id. at para. 174. The Inter-American Court found that the familial rights under articles 11.2 (right to private and family life) and 17.1 (right to protection of the family) of the American Convention apply equally to same-sex and opposite-sex couples. See id. at para. 199. Accordingly, the Inter-American Court concluded that under Article 1.1 (right to non-discrimination) and Article 24 (right to equal protection) of the American Convention, States must administer rights and benefits of marriage equally and without discrimination on the basis of the couple being of the same or opposite sex. See id.

The Inter-American Court specifically highlighted the following marital rights and responsibilities that must be afforded to same-sex couples in equal respect to heterosexual couples: taxes, inheritance and property rights, rules of succession, authority to make medical decisions, the rights and benefits of survivors, birth and death certificates, professional ethics standards, financial restrictions on election contributions, workers’ compensation benefits, health insurance, and custody of the children. See id. at para. 197.

Notably, the Inter-American Court held that it was not sufficient for States to merely create an alternative legal institution, such as a civil union distinct from marriage, for same-sex couples. See id. at para. 224. Even if the civil union grants individuals the same rights afforded to married couples, having a separate institution with a distinct name indicates to same-sex couples that they are socially different from others in society, or in some circumstances, that society does not equally approve of same-sex relationships. See id. Accordingly, the Court concluded that creating separate institutions for same-sex and opposite-sex couples would constitute discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation. See id.

With respect to Costa Rica’s question, the Inter-American Court held that States are obligated to provide same-sex couples access, without discrimination, to all existing rights and benefits in the domestic legal system provided to opposite-sex couples. See id. at para. 228. The Inter-American Court stated that States are required to take necessary measures to ensure equality, whether those measures be legislative, judicial, or administrative. See id.

Additional Information

The Inter-American Court may issue judgments on contentious cases against one of the 20 States that have accepted its contentious jurisdiction, and may issue advisory opinions when requested by an Organization of American States Member State or an organ of the OAS.

For more information about the Court’s past jurisprudence on the discharge of soldiers based on sexual orientation and the entitlement of same-sex partners to social benefits, the Inter-American system, the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, or the Inter-American Court, please visit IJRC’s Online Resource Hub. For additional information on discrimination against individuals for their actual or perceived sexual orientation, see IJRC’s Thematic Research Guide on LGBTQ persons.

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Post navigation

Previous Post:Pardon of Former Peruvian President Fujimori Raises Legal Questions
Next Post:UN Urges Tunisia to Ensure Rights Following Protests, Mass Arrests

COVID-19 & Human Rights Oversight

See human rights bodies' COVID-19 guidance on our dedicated webpage, organized by mechanism and theme, and updated regularly.

For human rights bodies' schedule and activity changes due to the pandemic, see our Monthly Overview posts or the IJRC Hearings & Sessions Calendar.

Human Rights Document Search

Upcoming Hearings & Sessions

  • June 1, 2023
    • Annual Mtg Treaty Body ChairsAnnual Mtg Treaty Body Chairs

      The Chairpersons of the UN human rights treaty bodies will hold their annual meeting in New York from May 29 to June 2.
      all day

Subscribe to the News Room


Search this Site

About IJRC

The International Justice Resource Center (IJRC) informs, trains, and advises advocates and individual victims on using international and regional human rights protections to advance justice and accountability in their communities.

Donate Today!

PayPal Giving Fund

Join Our Mailing List

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish.Accept Read More
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Save & Accept